Why are Christmas trees ALWAYS satanic, but wind chimes could swing both ways?
My Japanese mother-in-law is Buddhist. However, she enjoys celebrating the Christmas holiday by decorating tree with various Christmas ornaments. She is not worshipping the tree; she just thinks it’s a “fun custom.” She is not celebrating the birth of Jesus – since she does not believe in Christianity.
She also has some wind chimes that purchased about 15 years ago in Pike Place Market (Seattle). I’m not sure what she thinks about the wind chimes, but some Buddhists think they are useful in chasing away bad spirits.
On this subject, the Watchtower writes:
"If one’s motive in putting up a wind chime has nothing to do with false religion, superstition or demonism, and there is little possibility of others’ getting the wrong impression regarding its use in the home, it is a simple matter for personal decision."
Why doesn’t the WTS come to the same conclusion about Christmas trees? It seems to me that the key difference is simple: the Watchtower (JW leadership) allows Witnesses to put up wind chimes, but has decided not to allow Witnesses to put up a Christmas tree. Similarly, piñatas, the exchange of wedding rings, and baby showers, all have "pagan" origins, but the Watchtower has decided to allow Witnesses to have them if they so desire. It’s all based on the whims of a few elderly men in New York.
So why not rewrite the policy on Christmas trees to read:
"If one’s motive in putting up a Christmas tree has nothing to do with false religion, superstition or demonism, and there is little possibility of others’ getting the wrong impression regarding its use in the home, it is a simple matter for personal decision."
Would that be fair and logical?
Thanks Uncle Thesis: We did put up a Christmas tree (a fake one) several weeks ago. And as far as I know, no one in my family prostrated him/herself before it in worship. So I conclude that there’s nothing wrong with the tree and that it’s just a fun custom.
Technorati Tags: baby showers, birth of jesus, christmas holiday, christmas ornaments, christmas tree, christmas trees, demonism, elderly men, false religion, fun custom, google, japanese mother, personal decision, pike place market, pike place market seattle, script type, watchtower, wind chime, Wind Chimes, wrong impression